Red or ginger?

I thought for a long time. I want a change something in my hair. I allways loved gingers... so i thought: Why not? But It´s little bit difficult. I´m natural brunette, so what if ginger colour is not good for me? I thought about red too. Many people told me that red is not colour for me. But what about ginger? I really don´t know. So I made two pictures and I will ask you. I won´t show you my photo with natural hair - you could be affected by it.

Here you can see me as redhead:

 

And here me as ginger:

 

 I´m really sorry for quallity and size of pictures... What do you think? Red, ginger or natural?

Thanks a lot, xoxo